In the summer of 1851 an American lock salesman opened the two most trusted locks in England: a Chubb detector lock on a Westminster strong-room door and the famous Bramah challenge padlock in Piccadilly. The English lock trade didn’t take it quietly. Here’s the whole story, told from the documents of the time.
25 min
to open a Chubb lock in Westminster, 22 July 1851
51 hours
spent on the Bramah padlock, over 16 days
200 gns
Bramah’s reward, paid to Hobbs as £210
30 days
in which a London locksmith failed to pick Hobbs’s own lock
Key takeaways
- The Great Lock Controversy of 1851 began when Alfred Charles Hobbs, in London for the Great Exhibition, showed that the best English locks could be picked.
- On 22 July 1851 he opened a six-lever Chubb detector lock on a strong-room door at 34 Great George Street, Westminster, in 25 minutes.
- Between 24 July and 23 August he picked the Bramah challenge padlock in a room above Bramah’s shop in Piccadilly, not at the Exhibition, working 51 hours over 16 days.
- Three arbitrators awarded him the 200 guineas on 2 September 1851; Bramah paid under protest.
- Hobbs stayed in London and founded the lock and safe firm that became Hobbs, Hart & Co.
In This Article

Fact sheet: the Great Lock Controversy of 1851
| What | A public dispute over whether English locks could be picked, triggered by A. C. Hobbs |
| When | July to October 1851, during and after the Great Exhibition |
| Where | The Crystal Palace; 34 Great George Street, Westminster; Bramah & Co., 124 Piccadilly |
| Who | Alfred Charles Hobbs (1812–1891), agent of Day & Newell of New York |
| Locks opened | A Chubb six-lever detector lock (22 July) and the Bramah challenge padlock (opened by 23 August) |
| Arbitrators | George Rennie FRS, Professor Edward Cowper of King’s College London and Dr J. R. Black of Kentucky |
| Reward | 200 guineas (£210), awarded 2 September 1851 |
| Counter-challenge | A London locksmith, Garbutt, failed to pick Hobbs’s lock in 30 days (11 September to 11 October 1851) |
| Main source | C. Tomlinson (ed.), Rudimentary Treatise on the Construction of Locks, compiled from Hobbs’s papers, 1853 |
Who was Alfred Charles Hobbs?
Alfred Charles Hobbs was born in Boston, Massachusetts, on 7 October 1812. His father, a carpenter, had come from London; his mother came from Welshpool in Wales. His father died when Alfred was small and left the family poor, so at ten he was sent to work on a farm, and as a teenager he tried a string of trades before finishing an apprenticeship in glass cutting at the Boston and Sandwich glass works.1
Glass door knobs led him to locks. He patented a way of fixing the knobs to their spindles, met the lock makers who bought them, and after short spells in partnership and selling locks and safes he became the salesman for Day & Newell of New York, makers of an expensive bank lock.1

His sales method was blunt: show the banker that his present lock could be opened. In January 1847, at a bank in Stamford, Connecticut, he opened the outer door and three locks on the vault in 23 minutes. Unsurprisingly, the bank bought a new lock. In 1848 he answered a newspaper challenge from a Mr Woodbridge of Perth Amboy, who offered $500 to anyone who could open his lock on a Herring safe in the reading room of the Merchants’ Exchange in New York. Hobbs opened it overnight and collected the money.1 (Earlier versions of this article placed that challenge in Lancaster, Pennsylvania: Hobbs was working at a bank in Lancaster when he read the advertisement, but the lock was in New York.)
The locks England trusted
Two English locks had a reputation for being unpickable. Joseph Bramah’s lock, patented in 1784, used a small tubular key that pressed a ring of sliders to different depths. Jeremiah Chubb’s detector lock, patented in 1818, used six precisely cut levers and a detector that jammed the lock if any lever was lifted too high, so the owner would know someone had tried it.2 We explain how it works in our article on the Chubb detector lock, and the wider story in the history of safe lock mechanisms.
Bramah was confident enough to put money on it. For years, anyone passing its shop at 124 Piccadilly could see a padlock in the window with a label promising 200 guineas to “the artist who can make an instrument that will pick or open this lock”.2 The firm and its lock have their own page: our history of Bramah locks.

Hobbs arrived with something to sell. Day & Newell’s “parautoptic” lock, invented by Robert Newell, had a key with interchangeable bits that could be rearranged into a new combination, and a mechanism screened from anyone probing the keyhole. Newell patented it in England on 15 April 1851 and in the United States on 10 June 1851.34
Hobbs left New York in April 1851 on the steamship Washington for Southampton, carrying the lock to exhibit and a small chest of his own tools. He later recalled the customs officer’s face when the box was opened.1


Timeline of the 1851 lock controversy
Timeline
- April 1851 Hobbs sails from New York to Southampton on the steamship Washington.
- 30 June Paul R. Hodge describes American lock-picking methods to the Institution of Mechanical Engineers in London.
- Before 21 July Hobbs picks a Chubb detector lock in a few minutes in front of a group of scientific men at the Crystal Palace.
- 22 July He opens a Chubb lock on a strong-room door at 34 Great George Street, Westminster, in 25 minutes.
- 24 July Work begins on the Bramah challenge padlock in a room at 124 Piccadilly.
- 23 August Hobbs shows the opened padlock to two of the arbitrators.
- 2 September The arbitrators award him the 200 guineas.
- 9 September Bramah & Co. pays £210 and protests against the award.
- 11 Sept to 11 Oct Garbutt, a London locksmith, fails to pick Hobbs’s own lock.
Sources for the timeline: Tomlinson’s treatise of 1853 and Hobbs’s own account of 1886.21
22 July 1851: the Chubb lock in Westminster
The controversy started inside the Crystal Palace. Hobbs told a party of scientific men that every lock then made in England could be picked easily, and to prove it he picked a Chubb detector lock in front of them in a few minutes. People who hadn’t been there questioned whether the test was fair.2
So on 21 July Hobbs wrote from the American department of the Exhibition to Chubb & Son at St Paul’s Churchyard, inviting them to watch him open one of their locks in use, on the door of a strong room at 34 Great George Street, Westminster. No member of the firm attended, though Hobbs later said Chubb sent a man to look on.21 The next morning eleven witnesses signed a statement:
“Mr. Hobbs commenced at 35 minutes past 11 o’clock A.M., and opened the lock within 25 minutes.”
Witnesses’ certificate, London, 22 July 1851

The lock threw three bolts and had six levers. It was on the iron door of a strong room built for valuable papers, formerly used by the agents of the South-Eastern Railway. The witnesses, who included G. R. Porter of the Board of Trade, confirmed that Hobbs had only been allowed to examine the keyhole, never the keys. Asked to lock it again with his instruments, he did so in seven minutes, without damage. The plate on the back read “Chubb’s New Patent … St. Paul’s Churchyard, London, Maker to Her Majesty”.2
Chubb’s supporters replied that this was an ordinary lock in use, not a test lock prepared for a challenge. Tomlinson answered that the lock was good enough to guard valuable papers and that the makers had been invited. He also noted that the detector, the feature meant to reveal an attempt, hadn’t been disturbed at all.2 In other words, the owner would never have known anyone had been at it.

The Bramah challenge: 51 hours over 16 days
Hobbs had stopped several times at Bramah’s window to look at the padlock. As he told it in 1886, he went into the shop, asked to handle the lock and felt the sliders with a penknife, then told one of the proprietors that the firm should either submit it to a fair trial or take it out of the window.1
The firm accepted, and three arbitrators were agreed: George Rennie FRS, the London engineer; Professor Edward Cowper of King’s College London; and Dr J. R. Black of Kentucky. The padlock was taken to an upper room, enclosed in a block of wood screwed to a door with the screws sealed, so that only the keyhole and hasp could be reached. The key was sealed up, the keyhole was covered with a sealed iron band whenever Hobbs was absent, and he was given 30 days.2

Hobbs began on 24 July. Work stopped for a time while Bramah asked to inspect the lock and the arbitrators considered the request, and resumed on 16 August. On 23 August Hobbs showed the open padlock to Black and Cowper (Rennie was out of town), and on 30 August the sealed key was brought out and shown to lock and unlock the padlock normally, proving it hadn’t been damaged. The arbitrators counted 16 working days and 51 hours in the room with the lock.2 A long way from the 25 minutes at Westminster.
Their award, dated 2 September 1851, concluded that Bramah & Co. had given Hobbs a fair opportunity and that he “has fairly picked or opened the lock”. They ordered the firm to pay the 200 guineas.2 Hobbs picked by public invitation, and today’s locksport hobbyists keep much the same rule: only your own lock, or one whose owner has said yes.
How he did it, in outline
Hobbs explained his method openly, and the 1853 treatise prints it. The lock had 18 sliders and a strong spring. He held the spring down with a fixed instrument screwed to the wooden block, kept a light turning pressure on the barrel, and felt for the notch in each slider in turn, recording its position on a strip of brass so he could resume each morning. False notches cut to deceive a picker repeatedly sent him back to the start.2 The principle he stated was simple: a lock can be picked whenever pressure on the bolt shows, through the parts the key touches, where the resistance lies.
Bramah’s protest
Bramah paid up, £210 on 9 September, but not quietly: it protested in writing. Its main objections were that no one had watched Hobbs at work during the 16 days, that the arbitrators hadn’t tried the key until he’d finished, and that he had used a fixed apparatus screwed to the wooden block, which, the firm argued, couldn’t be used on a real iron door. It also complained that Hobbs had taken a wax impression of the keyhole well before the trial (Bramah dated this 2 June; the treatise says 2 July).2
In October the firm told the Observer that the padlock hadn’t been taken apart for many years and was inferior in three respects to its current locks, and in 1853 it wrote that the sliders were iron rather than steel, the keyhole too large and the barrel only half its proper length. Bramah fitted the lock with its current improvements and put the padlock back in the window with the challenge renewed, now adding that applications had to be made in writing. According to Tomlinson an application was made, and the challenge was then withdrawn.2

How old was the padlock? Sources disagree. A newspaper report in 1851 said it had been made “forty years since” by Henry Maudslay when he worked for Bramah, and Bramah wrote in 1853 that it had been made “nearly forty years” earlier. Maudslay, however, left Bramah’s firm in 1797.5 The Science Museum Group dates its padlock, catalogued as the challenge lock of the 1851 controversy, to 1801, while many modern accounts give 1790.6
Could anyone pick Hobbs’s lock?
The English trade struck back. A challenge was attached to the Day & Newell lock at the Exhibition, and a London locksmith and engineer named Garbutt, who had once worked for Bramah, accepted it. Three arbitrators met at 20 Knightsbridge on 10 September 1851. Garbutt examined a ten-tumbler lock taken to pieces in front of him, then had exclusive access to the keyhole for 30 days, from 11 September, with £200 at stake. On 11 October he handed it back unopened and undamaged.2 That left the score at two English locks opened and one American lock unbeaten.
The official jury for locks at the Exhibition stayed cautious. Its report doubted whether picking a lock under conditions a burglar could never obtain was a fair test of its insecurity, while describing Hobbs’s American lock as seeming “to be impregnable”. Fraser’s Magazine mocked the jury for apparently being the only people in England who hadn’t heard of the controversy.2
Did you know?
The jewel case that held the Koh-i-Noor diamond at the Great Exhibition was made by Chubb & Son. It could raise and lower the diamond without being unlocked, and the official catalogue called it “impossible to pick”.7
Aftermath: what changed after 1851
The controversy didn’t ruin either English firm, but it changed how locks were designed and sold. Tomlinson’s treatise, published in 1853, records the responses.
Chubb
Curtains and new bolts
Chubb bought the right to John De la Fons’s 1846 patent combining a rotating barrel and curtain that closes the keyhole to extra instruments, patented a “tumbler-bolt” and introduced a new bank lock.2
Bramah
Steel sliders
Bramah said the defects of the old padlock had been corrected: steel sliders, a smaller keyhole and more false notches. It renewed its challenge, then withdrew it after an application was made.2
Hobbs
The Protector lock
Hobbs designed a cheaper six-lever “protector” lock with a movable stump, so that pressure on the bolt no longer pressed against the levers and gave a picker nothing to feel.2

Hobbs’s lesson was that a lock is only secure if pressure on the bolt tells a picker nothing. Chubb, Bramah and Hobbs himself all redesigned their locks around that argument within two years.2
Hobbs’s English patents began in February 1852, and he became a figure of the London engineering world: he lectured to the Society of Arts and the Institution of Civil Engineers awarded him its Telford Medal.31

From Hobbs & Co. to Hobbs, Hart & Co.
Instead of going home, Hobbs set up a lock factory in London, planning to run it for three years and then sell. He hired a building in Cheapside and brought machinery to replace hand work; progress was slow, and after the third year a new factory was built outside the City, with Cheapside kept as the shop.1 The firm was registered as Hobbs & Co. in 1852, had become Hobbs, Ashley & Co. by 1855 and later traded as Hobbs, Ashley and Fortescue at 97 Cheapside.8
When his partner Ashley died in August 1860, Hobbs sold the business on condition that his name stayed on the sign. It became Hobbs, Hart & Co., at 76 Cheapside by 1864.18 By Hobbs’s own account the firm won much of the lock work of the Government and the Bank of England.1 The company was incorporated in 1887, made locks, safes and strong-room doors at the Wharncliffe Works in Arlington Street, and became part of Chubb in 1956.98 Hobbs “Protector” locks also turn up in other makers’ safes: Milner safes often used them between about 1852 and 1871.10
Got a Hobbs, Hart safe or lock at home? Start with the London address on the plate and with the lock itself: they’re your best clues for dating it. And before you move or buy one, have a look at our guide to buying a second-hand safe for what to check.
Back in America
Hobbs and his family left London in October 1860 and reached New York on 1 November. Through his friend Elias Howe he took charge of building and equipping a sewing-machine factory in Bridgeport, Connecticut, and from 1866 ran the works that became the Union Metallic Cartridge Company, where he was superintendent.1 He died in 1891.11
Myths and mistakes about the Great Lock Controversy
Hobbs picked the Bramah lock at the Great Exhibition.
He picked it in an upstairs room at Bramah’s shop, 124 Piccadilly. The Exhibition was where the controversy began.
He opened the Bramah lock first, then the Chubb.
The Chubb lock came first, on 22 July; work on the Bramah padlock began on 24 July.
It took him 51 hours non-stop.
The 51 hours were spread over 16 working days between 24 July and 23 August.
The Bank of England replaced all its locks with Day & Newell’s.
We found no evidence of this. Hobbs later said his London firm won much Bank of England work.
Hobbs, Hart & Co. was founded in 1851.
Hobbs & Co. was registered in 1852; the Hobbs, Hart name dates from after 1860.
Quick facts for students
If you’ve landed here from an English reading-comprehension exercise about the Great Lock Controversy of 1851, you’re in good company: many readers do. We can’t vouch for any particular test passage, but these are the facts as the sources of 1851–1853 record them:
The key facts
- Hobbs was an American, born in Boston in 1812, representing Day & Newell of New York.
- Chubb lock: 22 July 1851, 34 Great George Street, Westminster; opened in 25 minutes, relocked in 7.
- Bramah lock: work began 24 July 1851; 51 hours over 16 days; award signed 2 September 1851.
- Reward: 200 guineas, paid as £210 on 9 September 1851.
- Garbutt failed to pick Hobbs’s lock in 30 days (11 September to 11 October 1851).
Frequently asked questions
What was the Great Lock Controversy of 1851?
A public dispute in London, during the Great Exhibition, after the American A. C. Hobbs picked a Chubb detector lock and the Bramah challenge padlock, showing that the most trusted English locks could be opened without their keys.
Who was Alfred Charles Hobbs?
An American locksmith and salesman (1812–1891) for Day & Newell of New York. After 1851 he founded the London firm that became Hobbs, Hart & Co., then returned to the United States in 1860.
How long did it take Hobbs to pick the Bramah lock?
51 hours of work spread over 16 days, between 24 July and 23 August 1851.
How long did it take Hobbs to pick the Chubb lock?
Just 25 minutes, on 22 July 1851. Then he locked it again with his instruments in 7.
Did Hobbs get the 200 guineas?
Yes, though Bramah wasn’t happy about it. The arbitrators awarded it on 2 September 1851 and Bramah paid £210 (200 guineas) on 9 September, under protest.
Where is the Bramah challenge lock now?
A Bramah padlock catalogued as the challenge lock of the 1851 controversy is in the Science Museum Group collection.6
What happened to Hobbs, Hart & Co.?
It traded from 76 Cheapside, became a limited company in 1887 and became part of Chubb in 1956.
Sources:
- Samuel Orcutt, A History of the Old Town of Stratford and the City of Bridgeport, Connecticut (1886), part II, pp. 872–889: biography of A. C. Hobbs written at his request, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
- Charles Tomlinson (ed.), Rudimentary Treatise on the Construction of Locks, compiled from the papers of A. C. Hobbs (London: John Weale, 1853), chapter IX “The lock controversy”, including the witnesses’ certificate of 22 July 1851, the arbitrators’ award of 2 September 1851 and Bramah & Co.’s letters, via Project Gutenberg. ↩︎
- George Hayter Chubb, Protection from Fire and Thieves (1875), appendix: list of English patents for locks, via Project Gutenberg. ↩︎
- Robert Newell, US Patent 8,145, “Permutation safety-lock”, 10 June 1851, via Google Patents. ↩︎
- Grace’s Guide, “Joseph Bramah”. ↩︎
- Science Museum Group, “Bramah padlock and key”, object 1972-290. ↩︎
- Official Descriptive and Illustrated Catalogue of the Great Exhibition (1851), vol. 2, Class 22, exhibit 646 (Chubb & Son), pp. 663–664, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
- The Chubb Archive, “The Aubin Trophy” (history of Hobbs & Co. and Hobbs, Hart & Co.). ↩︎
- Grace’s Guide, “Hobbs, Hart and Co”, citing the Stock Exchange Year Book (1908) and Whitaker’s Red Book (1914). ↩︎
- safeman.org.uk, “Safe scrapbook”. ↩︎
- Science Museum Group, “Alfred Charles Hobbs”. ↩︎
The History of Safes letter
One old safe a month, in your inbox
Once a month I send one safe worth a closer look, the new maker histories and a find from the patent and advert collection. Nothing else, and you can leave with one click.
You'll get a confirmation email first. One email a month, unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy.



