Willie Sutton robbed banks and jewellers on and off for two decades, broke out of three prisons and became the FBI’s eleventh “Ten Most Wanted” fugitive. He’s best remembered for a line he said he never spoke. Here’s what the records show.
11th
name added to the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted list (1950)
97 ft
the Eastern State tunnel he escaped through in 1945
5 years
on the run after the Holmesburg escape, 1947 to 1952
1976
the year he wrote “I never said it”
Key takeaways
- William Francis Sutton (1901–1980) was a Brooklyn-born robber known as “The Actor” and “Slick Willie” because he robbed in disguise.
- His documented robberies were hold-ups with staff present, not night-time safe jobs. The uniform of a messenger, postman or police officer got him through the door.
- He escaped from Sing Sing in 1932, Eastern State Penitentiary in 1945 (caught within minutes) and Holmesburg in 1947.
- Arnold Schuster, the young Brooklyn man who recognised him in 1952, was shot dead three weeks later. Nobody was ever charged.
- “Because that’s where the money is” was printed as his answer from 1951, but in his 1976 memoir Sutton wrote that he never said it.
In This Article

Willie Sutton at a glance
Willie Sutton was an American bank robber who worked from the 1920s until his capture in Brooklyn on 18 February 1952. He robbed in daylight, in disguise, and he was as famous for getting out of prison as for getting into banks. The FBI added him to its Ten Most Wanted list on 20 March 1950, the eleventh name on it.1
| Full name | William Francis Sutton |
| Born | 1901, Brooklyn, New York |
| Died | 2 November 1980, Spring Hill, Florida, aged 79 |
| Nicknames | “The Actor”, “Slick Willie” |
| Known for | Bank and jewellery robberies in disguise; prison escapes |
| Robberies | “Over one hundred” bank robberies and over $2 million (EBSCO); “close to a million dollars” over two decades (Time, 1952) |
| Escapes | Sing Sing, 11 December 1932; Eastern State Penitentiary, 3 April 1945; Holmesburg, 10 February 1947 |
| Ten Most Wanted | Added 20 March 1950 (eleventh name on the list) |
| Captured | 18 February 1952, Brooklyn |
| Released | 24 December 1969 |
| Books | I, Willie Sutton (with Quentin Reynolds, 1953); Where the Money Was (with Edward Linn, 1976) |
The robbery figures are estimates, and they don’t agree. EBSCO’s biography gives “more than one hundred” bank robberies and over $2 million; Time, writing the week he was caught, said he’d taken “close to a million dollars” from banks and jewellery stores in two decades.23 We couldn’t find anyone who has counted the robberies from court records, so treat any round number as a guess.
Early life and first sentences
Sutton was born in Brooklyn in 1901, the fourth of five children in an Irish American family, and left school after the eighth grade in 1916.2 Eastern State Penitentiary’s historians say his criminal career began with a burglary at the age of nine.4 He worked for a while in offices, including a trust company and an insurance firm, then stole $16,000 from the business of his girlfriend’s father; according to EBSCO’s biography he got a suspended sentence and went on to learn from a safecracker, Eddie “Doc” Tate.2
That’s about as close as Sutton came to the safe-cracking trade this site usually writes about. The craft of the night-time “yeggs” with drills and explosives, described in our history of safe-cracking, isn’t what made his name. His fingerprint record tells a plainer story. Sing Sing received him on 7 April 1926 for third-degree burglary, with a sentence of five to ten years, and he was paroled on 6 September 1929. On 25 November 1930 New York police arrested him again, for assault and robbery, and he was sent back to Sing Sing with 30 years.1
EBSCO’s account describes the 1926 conviction as an attempted bank robbery and ties the 30-year sentence to a robbery at a jewellery shop.2 The FBI’s card lists only the charges, so we’ve used its wording.
“Willie the Actor”: robbery in uniform
The nickname came from the costumes. Eastern State’s historians say he “sometimes dressed up as a mailman, messenger, or even a police officer when robbing a bank”, and EBSCO adds a maintenance man to the wardrobe.42 The FBI’s 2018 summary says he earned both nicknames for “his ingenuity in executing robberies in various disguises”, and that he was known as an immaculate dresser.1
Sutton’s own explanation, in I, Willie Sutton, is that people look at the uniform, not the face: “The right uniform was an open sesame that would unlock any door.”5 That’s his account, written with a journalist after his capture, and it’s the only detail of method we’ll give here. The point for a safe historian is what’s missing. In none of the robberies below did anyone need to defeat a vault door, because the staff were there to open it.

The best-documented robberies
Most of Sutton’s jobs survive only as totals. These are the ones we could pin to a date, a place or a sentence in a source we opened:
| Date | Target | What the sources say | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1930 | New York (EBSCO: a jewellery shop) | Arrested 25 November 1930 for assault and robbery | 30 years, Sing Sing |
| 1933 | Corn Exchange Bank, Philadelphia | Sutton came disguised as a postman; abandoned when a passer-by grew suspicious | No robbery |
| 15 January 1934 | Corn Exchange Bank & Trust Co., 60th and Ludlow Streets, Philadelphia | A $10,800 hold-up with two accomplices; Eastern State calls it a “machine gun robbery” | Arrested 6 February 1934; 25 to 50 years |
| Undated (before 1952) | Manufacturers Trust Co., a branch in Queens, New York | $63,942 taken | Tried in Queens in 1952; 30 more years |
The Philadelphia details come from the Inquirer and EBSCO; the arrest date and the 25-to-50-year sentence for armed robbery (with two further bills for unlawfully possessing a machine gun) are on the FBI card, entered when the state penitentiary received him on 12 February 1934.6241 The Queens figure is from Time in 1952, and the extra 30 years from the FBI.31 When Philadelphia caught him in 1934, he was also wanted in New York, having gone over the wall at Sing Sing.6
Prisons and escapes
Why did he keep breaking out? “Because I was in,” was his answer in Where the Money Was, and “there’s a thrill that comes from breaking out of jail”.6 The FBI’s 2018 summary says he escaped “a total of six times”; the Inquirer calls Holmesburg his sixth attempt, and Eastern State says he tried at least five times there alone.164 Three escapes can be dated from the sources:
| Date | Prison | In outline | How long he stayed out |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11 December 1932 | Sing Sing, Ossining, New York | Over the wall with a makeshift ladder | About 14 months: arrested in Philadelphia in February 1934 |
| 3 April 1945 | Eastern State Penitentiary, Philadelphia | With ten or eleven other men, through a tunnel dug by another prisoner | Minutes: caught two blocks away |
| 10 February 1947 | Holmesburg (Philadelphia County Prison) | Five men in prison guards’ uniforms, with ladders | Five years: arrested in Brooklyn, 18 February 1952 |
The Eastern State tunnel, 1945
Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia, designed by John Haviland and in use by 1830, received Sutton in 1934 to serve 25 to 50 years.4 The famous escape wasn’t his work. Clarence “Kliney” Klinedinst, a burglar trusted to repair the prison’s plaster and stonework, got permission to re-plaster his own cell, number 68 in Cellblock 7, and dug a tunnel behind a wooden panel. It ran about 15 feet down, 97 feet out towards Fairmount Avenue and 15 feet up, with lights and wooden bracing.4

Early on 3 April 1945 Klinedinst and his cellmate broke through to the street, and a group of prisoners followed; the site’s own transcripts give the number as ten and as eleven besides Sutton.4 Sutton didn’t get far. His statement afterwards is one of the best details in the whole story: once out, he was soaked and muddy, looked back, saw his own muddy footprints leading down the street and knew he was in trouble. He was caught within minutes, two blocks from the prison.4
He later claimed public credit for designing and building the tunnel.4 The prison filled it with ash from its incinerator, and archaeologists excavated the entrance in 2005.4 His sentence grew too, though the sources differ on how: the Inquirer says 10 to 20 years were added, EBSCO says he got life as a fourth-time offender.62 On 24 October 1945 he was moved to Holmesburg, the Philadelphia County Prison.1
Holmesburg, 1947
Sutton called the next one “my masterpiece” in Where the Money Was, “because it was impossible”.6 On 10 February 1947 he and four other men, wearing prison guards’ uniforms, crossed the yard with ladders and went over the wall. When a tower watchman saw them, Sutton told him it was an emergency, and the watchman accepted it.6 Time had the same scene in 1952: Sutton in a guard’s uniform, waving to the real guards.3 The man who made a career of looking as if he belonged did it once more, and this time he stayed out for five years. For an escape artist of a very different kind, who did it on stage and in front of the press, see Houdini and the locks and safes he took on.
Ten Most Wanted, capture in 1952 and the Schuster killing
The FBI added Sutton to its Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list on 20 March 1950, the eleventh person on it. Because he was so fond of expensive clothes, the FBI says, his photograph went to tailors as well as to police departments.1 It’s hard to think of a better tribute to a man’s suits.
It worked, in a roundabout way. On 18 February 1952 Arnold Schuster, a 24-year-old who worked in his father’s shop in Brooklyn, saw Sutton sitting opposite him on the subway.7 He had studied Sutton’s picture on an FBI flyer posted in the shop.8 He followed him to a filling station, where Sutton was buying a battery for a stalled 1951 Chevrolet, and told two patrolmen in a radio car. Patrolmen Joseph McClellan and Donald Shea and Detective Louis Weiner made the arrest; Police Commissioner George Monaghan called it “the best collar in recent years” and promoted the two patrolmen.3 The commissioner only learned of Schuster’s part a day later.3
The killing of Arnold Schuster
Schuster’s role was widely publicised, and he immediately received threats against his life, which he reported to the police.8 On the evening of 8 March 1952 he was shot dead in the street a few doors from his home on 45th Street in Brooklyn.78 He was 24.
Sutton was already in custody, and he was never charged with the killing. Nobody else was either. When New York’s highest court ruled on the family’s lawsuit in November 1958, it noted that “no individual has been indicted thus far for Schuster’s murder”.8 The police files, rediscovered in 2004, show more than 4,000 people interviewed, and the case was never solved.7 Theories about who ordered it have circulated ever since; no court has tested any of them, so we don’t repeat them here.
The lawsuit itself made legal history. In Schuster v. City of New York the Court of Appeals held that the city “owes a special duty to use reasonable care for the protection of persons who have collaborated with it” in arresting criminals, and that the family’s claim deserved its day in court.8
Back to prison
When he was caught, Sutton still owed a life sentence plus 105 years, according to the FBI, and the Queens conviction for the Manufacturers Trust robbery added 30 years more.12 EBSCO says he served it at Attica, where he read law and became a jailhouse lawyer.2
“Because that’s where the money is”: the quote he denied
Ask why Willie Sutton robbed banks and almost everyone knows the answer. The FBI’s own 2018 summary gives it straight: “When asked why he robbed banks, Sutton simply replied, ‘Because that’s where the money is.'”1 So does a tour of Eastern State, with an important rider: he “spent his entire life denying ever saying this”.4
We went looking for the line in print, using the newspaper trail Quote Investigator has already dug up. It appears with Sutton’s name in The Saturday Evening Post of 20 January 1951 (“I rob banks because that’s where the money is”), in The New Yorker of 1 March 1952, two weeks after his arrest, and in an interview in The American Weekly Sunday supplement of 30 March 1952. It wasn’t new even then: in December 1923 the Detroit Free Press quoted a young bank robber called Paul Perritt saying “We specialized on banks because that’s where the money is.”9
“I never said it.”
Willie Sutton, Where the Money Was (1976)
Sutton’s own verdict came in 1976, in a chapter of Where the Money Was called “Sutton’s Law”. He wrote that he never said it and that “the credit belongs to some enterprising reporter who apparently felt a need to fill out his copy”.9 His real reason, as he put it in the same book, was simpler: “Because I enjoyed it.”65 Take both books for what they are: his account, written with professional writers, by a man who’d had decades to polish the story.
Sutton’s law
The line he denied ended up in medical teaching. “Sutton’s law” means testing for the most probable diagnosis first, rather than chasing rare ones. Quote Investigator traces it to at least June 1963, when an article in The New York Times referred to “the medical equivalent of Sutton’s Law, named in honor of the bank robber”.9 Sutton’s 1976 chapter of the same name describes it.9
What banks and the law changed in Sutton’s era
By the time Sutton started, the biggest American vaults were enormous. In November 1924 the York Safe and Lock Company was advertising six vault entrances, each ten feet thick, built for the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, as you can see in York’s 1924 Federal Reserve advert.10 And since the 1870s American bank vault doors had been fitted with time locks, clockwork locks that keep the door shut, whoever dials the combination, until the hour the bank sets.11 That’s how time locks beat the bank kidnappers of the nineteenth century.
Our reading, not a claim Sutton made: a vault like that leaves a robber two choices, attack the steel or come when the door is open. Sutton came when the door was open. Every robbery in the table above was a hold-up with people present, and none of the charges on his fingerprint record is for breaking into a safe.1 It’s the same lesson our guide to how bank vaults work keeps coming back to: steel slows burglars down, but it can’t help when the staff open the door.
Law
The 1934 Bank Robbery Act
From 18 May 1934, robbing a national or Federal Reserve member bank was a federal crime: up to 20 years, or 25 with a dangerous weapon. State courts kept their jurisdiction, and every sentence on Sutton’s record came from a state court.1212
Publicity
A face on every wall
The Ten Most Wanted list of 1950 put his photograph in front of the public, tailors included. A disguise works on a stranger. It worked less well once strangers had studied the face.18
Safes
A word for Mosler
Mosler publications quoted his 1953 memoir: “Those Mosler people certainly make safe safes.” More in our history of Mosler safes.13
We couldn’t find a source that ties a specific change in bank security to Sutton himself, and we haven’t invented one. What he shows is the gap that thick doors and time locks didn’t close: the bank during opening hours, with people inside who could be fooled or frightened. For robberies that went the other way, caught by the very things Sutton avoided, see our list of failed bank robberies and heists that came undone.
Release and later life

On 24 December 1969 New York’s penal authorities decided he didn’t have to serve the rest of his sentences, and Sutton walked out.1 He was nearly 70 and had emphysema; EBSCO says he and a lawyer had used the 1960s Supreme Court decisions on prisoners’ rights and police procedure to press for his release.62
Then came the oddest job of his life. New Britain Bank and Trust Co. of Connecticut hired him for a television advert for its photo credit card, and he got the best line: “Now when I say I’m Willie Sutton, people believe me.”5 He wrote Where the Money Was with Edward Linn, published by Viking in 1976.9 He moved to Spring Hill, Florida, to live with his sister, and died there on 2 November 1980, aged 79. His family buried him in Brooklyn.12
Willie Sutton myths and facts
Sutton said he robbed banks “because that’s where the money is”.
Newspapers printed it from 1951. In 1976 he wrote that he never said it and blamed a reporter.
Willie Sutton was a master safe-cracker.
His record lists burglary, robbery and assault. The robberies he’s known for were hold-ups with staff present.
He dug the famous Eastern State tunnel.
Clarence Klinedinst dug it. Sutton went through it, was caught within minutes and later took the credit.
Sutton was convicted over Arnold Schuster’s death.
He was in custody and never charged. Nobody has ever been convicted; the case is unsolved.
He robbed exactly 100 banks.
Nobody has a count from court records. Estimates run from “close to a million dollars” (1952) to over $2 million.
Sources for these points: Quote Investigator, the FBI record and 2018 summary, Eastern State Penitentiary, the 1958 Court of Appeals opinion, DNAinfo, EBSCO and Time.9148723
Frequently asked questions
Did Willie Sutton say “because that’s where the money is”?
He said he didn’t. The line was printed as his from 1951, but in Where the Money Was (1976) he wrote “I never said it” and credited a reporter. A bank robber in Detroit was quoted saying much the same in 1923.
What is Sutton’s law?
A rule of thumb in medicine: test for the most likely diagnosis first. It’s named after the quote attributed to Willie Sutton and was in use by 1963.
How many banks did Willie Sutton rob?
Nobody knows exactly. EBSCO’s biography says over one hundred bank robberies and more than $2 million; Time in 1952 said close to a million dollars from banks and jewellers over two decades.
Why was Willie Sutton called “The Actor”?
Because he robbed in disguise, dressed as a postman, messenger, police officer or maintenance man. The FBI also called him “Slick Willie”.
How many times did Willie Sutton escape from prison?
Three escapes are well documented: Sing Sing in 1932, Eastern State Penitentiary in 1945 and Holmesburg in 1947. The FBI’s 2018 summary says six in all; we couldn’t date the other three.
Who killed Arnold Schuster?
Nobody knows. Schuster was shot near his Brooklyn home on 8 March 1952, three weeks after Sutton’s arrest. No one was ever charged, and the case was never solved.
When did Willie Sutton die?
On 2 November 1980 in Spring Hill, Florida, aged 79, nearly 11 years after his release on Christmas Eve 1969.
Sources:
- Federal Bureau of Investigation, “February 2018: Criminal History of Bank Robber William Sutton”, FBI artifact of the month post (21 February 2018), with Sutton’s FBI identification record no. 241 884 (page 1, dated 3 June 1970); public domain copy via Wikimedia Commons. ↩︎
- Thomas L. Erskine, “Willie Sutton”, EBSCO Research Starters (2024). Its bibliography lists both of Sutton’s memoirs. ↩︎
- “Crime: The Actor & the Bulls”, Time (3 March 1952). ↩︎
- Eastern State Penitentiary Historic Site, audio tour transcript, stops “Slick Willie Sutton”, “Clarence Klinedinst” and the Cellblock 7 escape tunnel (Brett Bertolino, Elizabeth Williamson). ↩︎
- Steve Cocheo, “The unexpurgated search for Willie Sutton”, Banking Exchange (2 August 2012), quoting I, Willie Sutton and Where the Money Was. ↩︎
- Tommy Rowan, article on “Slick Willie” Sutton’s Holmesburg prison escape, The Philadelphia Inquirer (14 February 2025), quoting Where the Money Was (1976). ↩︎
- Ben Fractenberg, report on the unsolved Arnold Schuster murder and the NYPD case files, DNAinfo New York (8 March 2017). ↩︎
- Schuster v. City of New York, 5 N.Y.2d 75 (New York Court of Appeals, 11 November 1958), opinion of Judge Van Voorhis; text via vLex. ↩︎
- Quote Investigator, “Quote Origin: I Rob Banks Because That’s Where the Money Is” (10 February 2013), citing the Detroit Free Press (19 December 1923), The Saturday Evening Post (20 January 1951), The New Yorker (1 March 1952), The New York Times (16 June 1963) and Willie Sutton with Edward Linn, Where the Money Was (Viking, 1976), p. 120. ↩︎
- York Safe and Lock Co., “York Vaults” advertisement, The Bankers Magazine, New York (November 1924), via Internet Archive. ↩︎
- Mark Frank, “A brief history of the time lock industry”, my-time-machines.net (bank vault time lock collection). ↩︎
- Act of 18 May 1934, ch. 304, “To provide punishment for certain offenses committed against banks”, 48 Stat. 783 (U.S. Statutes at Large, via govinfo.gov). ↩︎
- Jim Blount, “Mosler Safe Co. reputation established by reports from 1871 Chicago fire, Fort Knox, White House, atomic bomb explosion, museums and frustrated safecrackers”, Lane Libraries, 2014, quoting a 1973 Mosler company history and Mosler publications (archived copy). ↩︎
The History of Safes letter
One old safe a month, in your inbox
Once a month I send one safe worth a closer look, the new maker histories and a find from the patent and advert collection. Nothing else, and you can leave with one click.
You'll get a confirmation email first. One email a month, unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy.


