The Battle of the Safes, 1867: Herring vs Chatwood in Paris

In August 1867, at the Paris Exposition, two teams of workmen attacked each other’s safes with hammers and wedges against the clock. Herring’s men got the block of wood out first; Chatwood’s men opened the challenge safe in 29 minutes. Both sides claimed victory, and the courts were still at it in 1872.

29 min

to open the doors of Herring’s challenge safe

235 min

to break the test block out of Chatwood’s safe

254 min

to finish Herring’s inner chest, by The Engineer’s count

30,000 fr

in stakes, 15,000 francs a side

Key takeaways

  • The trial took place on 13 and 14 August 1867 in the English Testing House on the Champ de Mars, between Silas C. Herring of New York and Samuel Chatwood of Bolton.
  • Each maker’s three workmen attacked the rival’s safe. The prize was 15,000 francs a side, with the surplus promised to charities in London, Paris and Washington.
  • Chatwood’s men opened Herring’s outer doors in 29 minutes, but the agreed target was a wooden block inside Herring’s inner chest. Herring’s men reached Chatwood’s block first, through the side of the safe, never the door.
  • The judging committee broke up on 20 August without a decision. Herring advertised himself as the winner; Chatwood advertised French court judgments in his favour, the last dated 27 December 1872.
Coloured bird's-eye view of the Paris Exposition of 1867: the oval exhibition palace on the Champ de Mars, its park of pavilions, and the Seine with the Pont d'Iéna in the foreground
Official bird's-eye view of the Exposition Universelle, Paris 1867, by Eugène Ciceri and Philippe Benoist. Public domain, Library of Congress via Wikimedia Commons.

The Battle of the Safes at a glance

WhatA challenge trial between two safes, each attacked by the other maker’s workmen
When13 August 1867 from 2.45 pm, finished on the morning of 14 August
WhereThe English Testing House, Exposition Universelle, Champ de Mars, Paris
ChallengerSilas C. Herring, New York (Herring, Farrel & Sherman)
Accepted bySamuel Chatwood, Bolton (Chatwood’s Patent Safe and Lock Co.)
Stakes15,000 francs each, held by M. Le Play, President of the Imperial Commission
CommitteeRobert Mallet and Robert F. Fairlie (for Chatwood); Joseph E. Holmes and Thomas B. Pickering (for Herring); P. Douliot, chairman; W. J. Hoyle, secretary
Test objectA sealed block of wood, a little smaller than a brick, inside each safe
TimesChatwood’s safe: 235 minutes. Herring’s outer doors: 29 minutes; inner chest finished at 254 minutes in all (other counts below)
OutcomeCommittee dissolved on 20 August 1867 without a decision; both makers claimed the win

Sources for the table: the committee’s articles and minutes, The Engineer and Sala’s account, all cited in the sections below.123

Paris, 1867: a safe test in a show house

The Exposition Universelle filled the Champ de Mars for most of 1867. Britain’s contribution to the park included an odd building called the English Testing House, where makers of stoves, locks, bells and kitchen gadgets could have their wares tried in public. George Augustus Sala, who was there, said it looked equally like a cottage, a Swiss chalet and a lodge to a gentleman’s park. It stood on the right of the Grand Avenue coming from the Pont d’Iéna, opposite the Imperial Pavilion.3

Both men had safes in the Exposition, in Class 65.1 Silas Herring was one of the best-known safe makers in America; his firm is in our history of Herring-Hall-Marvin safes. Samuel Chatwood, born at Edenfield in Lancashire in 1833, had founded his business at Bolton in his twenties and called himself a bankers’ safe and lock engineer.43 His safes had won medals at Dublin and Oporto in 1865, and Sala noted that the London watchmaker John Walker had switched to them after his own safe was broken open.3

That burglary matters to the story. Walker’s shop in Cornhill was robbed in February 1865 and about £5,000 worth of property was taken. The Engineer thought the robbery had done a good deal, indirectly, to improve British safes and to boost the trade of the safe makers, and in Paris it was Walker’s marine chronometer that kept the time.2 Chatwood went further: he wouldn’t let his men bring tools heavier than those used in the Cornhill job.3

The challenge: May to July 1867

Herring started it. A notice dated 15 May 1867 offered two contests, each for a stake of 1,000 to 50,000 francs: a fire test of his fireproof safe against any safe in the Exposition, and a test “by experts” of his burglar-proof safe, “secured by Yale’s Patent Combination Lock”, against any safe on show. The offer was open until 15 June.1

Chatwood accepted the burglar-proof challenge by letter from the Grand Hotel on 5 June. His terms: a committee of five engineers (two English chosen by him, two American or other chosen by Herring, and a French fifth chosen by those four), full working drawings of both safes, and 15,000 francs a side, with the winner taking 15,000 and the balance, after expenses, split between charities in Paris, London and Washington.3

Then came three weeks of letters. Herring dropped the questions of construction and workmanship and wanted the test confined to materials and resistance to drills, gunpowder, wedges, crowbars and screws. He said his lock had no keys and he couldn’t supply full drawings, and he offered a different safe, left at Le Havre after damage in shipping, because the American commissioner-general had told him the exhibited safes couldn’t be tested. Chatwood refused to let the ground shift: it was to be the safe with the notice on it. On 29 June he signed off with “With me time is money”.3 You can almost hear the pen digging into the paper.

The Articles of Agreement were signed in Paris on 9 July 1867. They named the safes exhibited on 5 June, gave the committee a free hand to “employ such means as they may think best”, and asked it to say which safe was best in materials and in resisting drills, gunpowder, steel wedges, crowbars, steel screws “or any other kind of burglars’ appliances”. Both stakes went to M. Le Play, President of the Imperial Commission.1 In sterling that was £600 a side.5

The rules, the committee and the tools

The committee was Robert Mallet and Robert F. Fairlie, civil engineers of London, for Chatwood; Joseph E. Holmes and Thomas B. Pickering of New York for Herring; P. Douliot as the French chairman; and W. J. Hoyle as secretary and interpreter.13 Douliot spoke no English, which The Engineer flagged at the time and which the English members later blamed for much of what went wrong.26

Two disputes were settled on the morning of the trial itself. The first was the target. Shortly before the trial Herring added a note to his posted challenge saying only the small inner chest of his safe was to be attacked, so Chatwood’s men would have to get through the outer safe and then a second, smaller one. The Mechanics’ Magazine called it an “unwarrantable and clandestine proceeding”; the committee let it stand.57 A sealed block of wood was put in each safe, and getting it out first counted as one proof of victory, though not the only one.3

The second was tools. The committee had agreed each side could bring anything that counted as a burglar’s appliance, the practical limit being what a burglar could carry without being noticed. Chatwood’s men arrived with a portmanteau 22 inches long, a small gun case and a leather courier’s bag. Herring’s men arrived with two large packing cases on a truck.6 The committee resolved that both sides should have an equal weight of tools, rejected Herring’s heaviest pieces as not being burglars’ implements, and then, at the American members’ request, allowed Herring’s men extra weight. Mallet and Fairlie said they agreed only so the trial could go ahead at all, and that the concession was abused.6

As certified after the trialHerring’s safeChatwood’s safe
Gross weight4,110 lb2,912 lb
Outside height4 ft 8¾ in2 ft 11¾ in
Fireproof filling5 in thick, about 1,836 lb3½ in thick, 353 lb
DoorDouble outer doors, plus an inner chestSingle door
Tools used by the attackersHerring’s men on Chatwood’s safe: 116 pieces, 242 lbChatwood’s men on Herring’s safe: 148 pieces brought, 145½ lb, about 40 lb never used
All tools brought160 pieces, 468 lb (including rejected tools and two packing cases)150 pieces, 157½ lb (including two cases)
Lists certified by R. Crighton for Chatwood and F. B. Taylor for Herring, printed with the English members’ report. Safeman.org.uk rounds the totals to 469 lb and 145 lb.

Sources for the table: the certified lists and the safeman summary.67 Herring’s list carries a dry footnote of its own: it doesn’t include the tools his men took away on the night of the trial.6

The test, 13 and 14 August 1867

The trial was meant to begin at eleven. With the tools argument and the safes still being set in position, it didn’t start until 2.45 pm.63 Only fifty tickets were issued. The two safes stood side by side with a canvas screen between them so neither team could see the other, the committee watched from the front, and neither Herring nor Chatwood was allowed to give his men so much as a gesture.3

Herring’s men were Germans: Sala names them as Eric Doelen, Frederic Ruder and Herman Winkler (Mallet and Fairlie call the first one Eric Dillon). Chatwood’s were his own Lancashire workmen, Robert Crighton, John Blakeman and George Plant.367 The noise, Sala wrote, could be heard far across the park, and the sergents de ville had to hold back a crowd outside.3

Herring’s men on Chatwood’s safe

According to the English members, one of the Germans began by putting a ready-made key into Chatwood’s lock; it fitted but wouldn’t turn, and Mallet and Fairlie thought it failed only because Chatwood had been allowed to change a lever in his lock the day before. The team then tried the lock, set up a ratchet drilling frame on the door, and broke a number of drills on Chatwood’s “intersected” steel without getting through. Punches, a sledge hammer and a cross-cut chisel on the keyhole and the top joint of the door failed too.63

So they left the door alone. With cold setts, wedges, the sledge and a six-foot steel crowbar they split the dovetailed joints at the top and one side and opened up the flank of the safe (Sala and safeman.org.uk say the right side, Mallet and Fairlie the left). At 7.25 pm they pulled the block of wood out of the hole, and the Americans in the room cheered.367 Chatwood’s side made the obvious objection: a safe in use would be built into brickwork, and the door had never given way.3

“Breaking a safe to pieces by sheer force is no more opening a safe than an earthquake is a burglary.”

George Augustus Sala, The Battle of the Safes, 1868

Chatwood’s men on Herring’s safe

Chatwood’s men took off the hasp of Herring’s double doors, drove wedges along the joint where the two leaves met, and had both outer doors open at 3.14 pm: 29 minutes.37 For Chatwood, that was the challenge safe opened with ordinary burglars’ tools in under half an hour. For the trial, it was only the start. They cleared out the wooden shelving and began on the inner chest, set low in the safe under the fittings, where the light from the high windows barely reached.36

They had to do it without their sledge hammer for the first 70 minutes. It had been allowed in but left outside through a misunderstanding, and the committee only confirmed the permission at 3.55 pm.6 By the evening the front of the chest had been wedged open enough for a hand to reach in, but not enough to get the block out. Work stopped at 7.40 pm. Next morning, in front of the committee, they finished the job: three and a half minutes by the English members’ watches, five by Pickering’s, and four by agreement.63

Timeline

  • 15 May 1867 Herring dates his challenge, posted on his safe in the Exposition.
  • 5 Jun 1867 Chatwood accepts from the Grand Hotel, Paris.
  • 9 Jul 1867 Articles of Agreement signed; 15,000 francs a side.
  • 13 Aug, 2.45 pm The trial begins in the English Testing House.
  • 13 Aug, 3.14 pm Herring’s outer doors are open.
  • 13 Aug, 5.47 to 6.33 pm Both teams stop to rest and eat.
  • 13 Aug, 7.25 pm Herring’s men take the block out of Chatwood’s safe.
  • 14 Aug, morning Chatwood’s men finish Herring’s inner chest in about four minutes.
  • 20 Aug 1867 The English members withdraw, the chairman resigns, the committee ends.
  • 27 Dec 1872 Paris Court of Appeal decree in Chatwood’s favour, as his adverts report it.

Timeline sources: the agreement, Sala, the English members’ report, The Engineer and Chatwood’s 1873 advert.13628

How long did it take? Three sets of numbers

Everyone agrees on 29 minutes for Herring’s outer doors. After that, the sums depend on who’s doing them. The Engineer started both clocks at 2.45 pm, took off the 45-minute break and got 235 minutes for Chatwood’s safe and 254 for Herring’s chest. It conceded that on the agreed conditions, “and small as was the difference”, the time favoured Herring, then argued that fair allowances could make the 19 minutes vanish or even reverse.2

The Engineer also made a point that both camps tend to leave out. At about 7.20 pm, 230 minutes in, Chatwood’s men had opened Herring’s chest along its full length to a gap of two and a quarter inches: too narrow for the block, which Herring had “wisely” put at the very bottom of the chest, but plenty to lift out gold coin or jewels. By that measure, the journal said, Herring’s safe was effectively broken five minutes before Chatwood’s.2

SourceChatwood’s safeHerring’s safe and chest
The Engineer, 30 Aug 1867235 min230 min to a hand-sized opening; 254 min to finish the chest
Mechanics’ Magazine, 14 Feb 1868235 min29 min for the doors plus 210 for the chest: 239 min
safeman.org.uk232 min29 min plus 225 for the chest: 254 min
The Mechanics’ Magazine figures come from its reading of the English members’ report; safeman.org.uk doesn’t give a source for its 232 minutes.

Sources for the table: The Engineer, the Mechanics’ Magazine and safeman.org.uk.257 Mallet and Fairlie added their own list of handicaps for Chatwood’s men: the late start, which left Herring’s safe in poor light behind the screen; the missing sledge; the crowd that burst in at 7.25 pm and wrecked the last quarter of an hour; and, they admitted, the beer and brandy at the break, after which the Germans came back as sober as before and Chatwood’s men didn’t.6 Read the three accounts side by side and the minutes start to matter less than the arguments about them.

The verdict that never was

The arguing started before the dust settled. On the morning of 14 August one of the English members noticed a pencilled bill on one of Herring’s safes in the machinery zone headed “America again victorious”.6 The committee agreed that each member would write up his views separately for the chairman. Instead, the two Americans sent Douliot a joint report, and Holmes added a long private letter of his own; Mallet and Fairlie then sent a joint report too. When Mallet and Fairlie found out, they protested, and after a meeting that ran until 1.30 am on 20 August they resigned that evening. Douliot resigned on the spot, and the secretary offered to go too.2

The Engineer’s verdict on the verdict was blunt: the committee had dissolved without a decision, there was no power to reappoint it, and the stakes, it presumed, would have to go back to the two parties.2 That isn’t quite how it went. According to Chatwood, a report in Herring’s favour was adopted on 4 October at Douliot’s house by Douliot, Holmes and Pickering, with Mallet and Fairlie not told, and dated 5 October; the Manchester Examiner and Times printed it as the committee’s official report. Chatwood called it a “pretence” and said the Imperial Treasury refused to pay out the £1,200 on the strength of it.9

Then the lawyers took over. Safeman.org.uk says a Tribunal of First Instance in Paris declared the judgment null and void the following year, with costs against Herring.7 Chatwood’s own advert in the British catalogue for the Vienna Exhibition of 1873 cites a judgment of the Tribunal of First Instance in a case brought by Herring against Chatwood (the name of a second defendant is garbled in the scan), given in Chatwood’s favour with costs against Herring, and a decree of the Paris Court of Appeal of 27 December 1872 confirming it.8 We haven’t been able to check either judgment against French court records, so the details rest on Chatwood’s advert and the safeman summary.

The advertising war

Whatever the courts said, both firms sold the result. Chatwood’s side got there first in print. Sala’s The Battle of the Safes, or British Invincibles versus Yankee Ironclads came out from Tinsley in 1868 at two shillings, casting Chatwood as Wellington and Herring as Napoleon, and printing Mallet and Fairlie’s report and the whole correspondence as an appendix.3 The Mechanics’ Magazine, reviewing that report in February 1868, declared Chatwood “really and truly the winner”.5

Herring answered in America. An advert of June 1872 in The Atlanta Constitution, also on our page for Herring’s 1872 Chicago fire advert, shows a Paris 1867 medal stamped “Herring’s Safes”, calls his safe the best in the world as awarded at the Paris Exhibition, and adds: “Also, winner of the wager of 30,000 Francs”.10 We found nothing to show the stakes were ever paid to Herring. The official American list is more modest: the US commissioners’ report gives Herring, Farrel & Sherman a bronze medal for fire and burglar-proof safes in Class 65.11 We searched the text of all six volumes of those reports and couldn’t find the contest mentioned at all.

Chatwood kept the fight going in Europe. His 1873 Vienna advert listed prize medals from Dublin, Oporto, Paris 1867 and Le Havre 1868, announced him “victorious in International Safes Challenge Contest, Paris Exhibition, 1867”, cited the two court rulings and offered the “Battle of the Safes” booklet post free.8 By 1876 his adverts were simply listing medals “wherever exhibited”, as on our page for Chatwood’s “Invincible” safes advert of 1876.12

Tall newspaper advert for Herring's safes with two exhibition medals, an open safe and a banner reading 30,000 Francs
Herring, Farrel & Sherman advertisement, The Atlanta Constitution, 14 June 1872, claiming the 30,000-franc wager. Public domain, via Internet Archive.

What it changed

Full-page advert showing an open Chatwood safe, an elephant trade mark and lists of prize medals
Chatwood’s Safe Depôt advertisement, Spons’ Illustrated Book of Prices for 1876, p. 137. Public domain, via Internet Archive (Google scan).

Both makers came out talking about metal. The safe Chatwood sent to Paris was, according to safeman.org.uk, his “Septuple Patent”, probably filled with haematite iron, which safeman.org.uk says was more prone to shattering; Sala’s description calls the range the “Sextiple Patent Invincible”. Spiegeleisen, patented in 1868, went into the “Octuple Patent”, and Chatwood’s price list of 1880 called it superior to the safe tested in Paris.73 By 1873 he claimed his was the only safe in the world sold subject to a 36-hour test with burglars’ appliances before delivery.8

Herring’s 1872 bankers’ safes were “steel-welded, combined with Patent Franklinite”, and advertised as proof against the drill, the blowpipe, wedges, nitroglycerine and gunpowder.10 Neither firm says in so many words that Paris made it change course, so read the sequence for yourself. The wider story of these attacks and defences is in our history of safe-cracking, and the Bolton side of it in our entry on Chatwood safes.

The contest’s real legacy is the argument it couldn’t settle: what counts as “broken into”, and whose clock to believe. The Engineer had to choose between a hand-sized gap and an extracted block, and it deducted the rest break so it was counting working minutes only.2 Modern ratings answer both questions in the rulebook. A UL TL-15 or TL-30 rating counts only net working time, the minutes when tools are actually on the safe.13 We found no source that links Paris 1867 directly to today’s TL-15 and TL-30 burglary ratings, so take this as a parallel, not a family tree.

Hobbs in 1851: the same quarrel, sixteen years earlier

The obvious comparison is London in 1851, when the American A. C. Hobbs opened a Chubb detector lock in 25 minutes and then picked Bramah’s challenge padlock over 16 days and 51 hours, winning 200 guineas that Bramah paid under protest.14 There’s the same American challenger, the same English champion, a panel of judges and the same fight afterwards over whether the method was fair. The difference is the tools. Hobbs worked on a lock, quietly, for weeks; Paris was an afternoon of sledge hammers on the whole safe, and that’s why Chatwood’s side kept insisting it was “boiler breaking” rather than burglary.6 The full 1851 story is in our article on Hobbs and the Great Lock Controversy.

Myths and facts

The judges declared Herring the winner.

The committee dissolved on 20 August 1867 without a decision. A later report for Herring was signed by the chairman and the two American members, according to Chatwood, who disputed it in court.

Herring’s men forced Chatwood’s door.

They tried the lock, the drill and the door joints and gave up. They broke in through the top and side of the safe.

The contest was held in July 1867.

The agreement was signed on 9 July; the trial itself ran on 13 and 14 August 1867.

Sources for the myths: The Engineer, Chatwood’s letter of November 1867, Sala and the English members’ report.2936

Frequently asked questions

What was the Battle of the Safes?

A challenge trial at the Paris Exposition of 1867 between the New York safe maker Silas C. Herring and Samuel Chatwood of Bolton. On 13 and 14 August each maker’s workmen attacked the other’s safe with burglars’ tools, against the clock, for a stake of 15,000 francs a side.

Who won the Battle of the Safes?

It depends whose account you read. On the agreed terms Herring’s men reached the test block first, by 19 minutes on The Engineer’s figures, but the committee broke up without a verdict and Chatwood later advertised French court rulings in his favour.

How long did it take to open the safes?

Herring’s outer doors were open in 29 minutes. Chatwood’s safe took 235 minutes (232 by one later count), and Herring’s inner chest 254 minutes in all, finished the next morning. The Mechanics’ Magazine gives 239.

What tools did they use?

The reports list drills and a ratchet brace, punches, chisels, cold setts, steel wedges, crowbars and sledge hammers. Herring’s men used 242 lb of tools; Chatwood’s men brought 145½ lb and didn’t use about 40 lb of it.

Where can I read the original reports?

The Engineer of 30 August 1867 and Sala’s The Battle of the Safes (1868), which reprints the English members’ report and the correspondence, are both free online; the links are in the sources below.

Sources:
  1. Articles of Agreement between Silas C. Herring and Samuel Chatwood, Paris, 9 July 1867, quoting Herring’s challenge dated 15 May 1867, printed in Sala, The Battle of the Safes (1868), pp. 34–35, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  2. The Engineer, 30 August 1867, pp. 169–171, “The French International Exhibition” and “The challenge competition of safes for the deposit of valuables at Paris” (report on the Herring and Chatwood safe trial), scan via The Engineer archive. ↩︎
  3. George Augustus Sala, The Battle of the Safes, or British Invincibles versus Yankee Ironclads (London: Tinsley, 1868), narrative pp. 5–27, correspondence of June 1867 in the footnotes pp. 12–19, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  4. Grace’s Guide, “Samuel Chatwood (1833-1909)”, with obituaries from Engineering (1909) and the Iron and Steel Institute (1910). ↩︎
  5. “The Battle of the Safes”, leader in the Mechanics’ Magazine, 14 February 1868, reprinted in Sala, The Battle of the Safes (1868), pp. 28–32, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  6. Robert Mallet and Robert F. Fairlie, official report of the English members of the Safes Testing Committee, with the committee’s minutes and the certified lists of safes and tools (pp. 46–47), printed as the appendix to Sala, The Battle of the Safes (1868), pp. 33 onwards, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  7. safeman.org.uk, “Battle of the Safes: safe-breaking contest, Paris Exhibition 1867” (archived copy). ↩︎
  8. Samuel Chatwood advertisement in The British Section at the Vienna Universal Exhibition, 1873, official catalogue (London, 1873), appendix p. 38, via Technisches Museum Wien library. ↩︎
  9. Samuel Chatwood, letter dated Bolton, 25 November 1867, Manchester Examiner and Times, 26 November 1867, reprinted in Sala, The Battle of the Safes (1868), pp. 25–26 (footnote), via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  10. Herring, Farrel & Sherman advertisement, The Atlanta Constitution, 14 June 1872, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  11. William P. Blake (ed.), Reports of the United States Commissioners to the Paris Universal Exposition, 1867, vol. I (Washington: Government Printing Office, 1870), p. 302, Class 65, bronze medals, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  12. Chatwood’s Safe Depôt advertisement, Spons’ Engineers’ and Contractors’ Illustrated Book of Prices for 1876 (London), p. 137, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  13. Dominic Schwebs, “TL-15 vs TL-30: Which High-Security Safe Do You Need?”, Safe and Vault Store, 15 May 2026. A dealer’s guide; its insurance figures are stated as general guidelines, not coverage commitments. ↩︎
  14. Charles Tomlinson (ed.), Rudimentary Treatise on the Construction of Locks, compiled from the papers of A. C. Hobbs (London: John Weale, 1853), chapter IX “The lock controversy”, including the witnesses’ certificate of 22 July 1851, the arbitrators’ award of 2 September 1851 and Bramah & Co.’s letters, via Project Gutenberg. ↩︎

The History of Safes letter

One old safe a month, in your inbox

Once a month I send one safe worth a closer look, the new maker histories and a find from the patent and advert collection. Nothing else, and you can leave with one click.

You'll get a confirmation email first. One email a month, unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy.

Hos Logo
Greg

I work in IT and I'm a designer at heart. I write this blog because safes turned out to be a surprisingly big slice of history and pop culture. Every article here is checked against period catalogues, patents and trade directories, and my favourite story is still the Great Lock Controversy of 1851.

Articles: 166

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.