Inventing the Fireproof Safe: Who Invented It and How Early Fire Safes Worked

No one person invented the fireproof safe. It took English patentees, New York ironmongers, a stereotype founder with a bag of plaster and a famous lawsuit to turn the iron chest into a box that could survive a burning building. Here’s who did what, and what’s probably packed inside the walls of an old one.

1801

earliest English fireproofing patent for safes we found

1833

Gayler’s double chest earns the name “Salamander”

$5,000

paid in 1839 for Fitzgerald’s plaster-of-Paris idea

212°F

the boiling point Milner promised its contents would not exceed

Key takeaways

  • Iron chests kept out thieves but not fire. Fire resistance came from double walls with a filling that insulated or gave off steam.
  • In England, Richard Scott patented fireproofing in 1801, followed by William Marr (1834), Thomas Milner (1840) and the Tanns (1843).
  • In New York, Jesse Delano patented a fire-resisting chest in 1826, C. J. Gayler’s double chest of 1833 gave us the word “Salamander”, and Daniel Fitzgerald’s plaster-of-Paris patent of 1843 was upheld by the US Supreme Court in 1850.
  • By the 1870s most British fire safes were filled with sawdust and alum, which release water as steam in a fire.
  • An old fire safe should not be trusted to protect documents today, and some 20th-century safes contain asbestos.

Fact sheet: who invented the fireproof safe?

Earliest English patentRichard Scott, fireproofing, 10 February 1801 (No. 2477)
Early American patentJesse Delano, New York, 1826; reissued 13 August 1834
“Salamander”Popular name first given to C. J. Gayler’s double chest after a fire in 1833
Plaster of ParisUsed by James Conner about 1829–1832; patented by Daniel Fitzgerald, 1 June 1843
British fillingsWilliam Marr (1834), Thomas Milner (1840), Edward, Edward Jr and John Tann (1843)
Main British filling by 1875Sawdust mixed with alum
Modern standardsUL 72 (United States); fire-resistance classes in European standards

Before fireproofing: iron chests

Strong boxes of the 18th and early 19th centuries were built against thieves. Cast-iron chests were being made for ordinary purposes from about the start of the 19th century; one of them, made by the Carron Company in Scotland, carries the earliest known surviving Chubb detector lock, No. 452 of December 1819.12

Fire was a different problem. Iron conducts heat, so a plain iron chest in a burning building simply baked whatever was inside. An American account of 1870 says the first portable “fire-proof” chests sold in New York were imported from France around 1830: a box of close-grained hardwood clad in iron plate, criss-crossed with iron bands and studded with nails with hollow round heads.1

Hand-coloured drawing of two iron chests covered in a grid of bands and round-headed studs, one on castors, both with doors open
Jesse Delano’s improved fire-proof wrought-iron chest, a hand-coloured drawing from his patent file (patented 1826, reissued 1834). US National Archives, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
Painting of the Great Fire of London seen from the river with flames over the city and Old London Bridge
The Great Fire of London (1666), painted by an unknown artist about 1675. Public domain.

The first fireproof safes in England

The list of English safe patents that George Hayter Chubb printed in 1875 opens with Richard Scott, who patented a method of fireproofing on 10 February 1801. We couldn’t find out anything more about Scott or his design, so for now he’s just a name and a date. The list continues with William Marr (13 February 1834), Thomas Milner (26 February 1840) and Edward, Edward junior and John Tann (25 November 1843), all for fireproofing, and William Milner in 1851 for fireproofing and bolts.3

Oval brass plate on a dark green safe door reading W. Marr, Patentee and Manufacturer, 52 Cheapside, London
Maker’s plate of William Marr, “Patentee & Manufacturer, 52 Cheapside, London”.

Marr’s safes carried brass plates like the one shown here, naming him as “patentee and manufacturer” at 52 Cheapside, London. Chubb‘s own first safe patent, in 1835, was for case-hardened plates against drills, not fire; the firm made safes in London from 1837.34

Two dates in earlier versions of this article don’t hold up, so we’ve corrected them here. A claim that Thomas Milner made tin-plate safes filled with sawdust and alum in 1827 comes from an American trade journal of 1878; his first patent is 1840. A claimed fireproofing patent by Charles Chubb in 1838 isn’t in his grandson’s list of safe patents.53 The Milner and Tann stories are told in our histories of Milner safes and John Tann & Sons.

New York: Delano, Conner and Gayler

The American side of the story is much easier to follow, thanks to a long account published in 1870 and a lawsuit that went all the way to the Supreme Court. Jesse Delano of New York made chests in the French pattern, and in 1826 patented an improvement: coating the wooden core with a mixture of clay, lime, plumbago and mica, or soaking it in potash lye and alum to make it incombustible. His patent was reissued on 13 August 1834.1

The same 1870 account tells a cautionary tale: one of these chests stood for years by the stove in a Hartford counting-house until, its fireproofing apparently exhausted, it caught fire on its own.1 Not quite what the owner had paid for.

Patent drawing of J. Delano's fire-proof safe, reissued 13 August 1834, showing the studded chest and its lock
Jesse Delano’s fire-proof safe patent, reissued 13 August 1834 (8356X). Public domain.

Why are old safes called “Salamanders”?

Lithograph of a man crouched inside a large open safe marked Patent Fire Proof Chest, surrounded by food, brandy and a barrel of ice
The Salamander Safe. A Millerite preparing for the 23rd of April, lithograph by Thomas S. Sinclair, 1843. Library of Congress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Charles J. Gayler of New York patented a “double” fire-proof chest in 1833: one chest inside another, with a space between them for air or another non-conductor. That same year one was caught in a fire that destroyed a large building in Thomaston, Maine, and came out with its contents in good order. An enthusiastic writer called it a “Salamander”, after the creature that legend said could live in fire, and the name has stuck to fire safes ever since.1

The great New York fire of December 1835 showed how few safes were really fireproof. Most of the so-called safes in the burnt district were simple iron closets; about sixty Gayler double chests were in use, and only a few of those saved their contents.1 By 1843 “Salamander safe” was famous enough for a satirical print, the one shown here, to show a believer in the end of the world hiding inside one, stocked up with food, brandy and a barrel of ice.

Plaster of Paris and the Wilder patent

The filling that made American safes reliable was plaster of Paris. James Conner, a New York stereotype founder who knew plaster didn’t conduct heat, built a double safe filled with it for his own counting room around 1829–1832 and used it until 1838.6 Daniel Fitzgerald arrived at the same idea independently, according to evidence given at the trial, experimented from 1830 and applied for a patent in 1836.6

In April 1839, long before his patent was granted, Fitzgerald sold the rights to Enos Wilder of New York for $5,000. The patent, granted on 1 June 1843 (US No. 3,117), describes two iron chests, one about three inches larger than the other, with the gap filled with calcined plaster mixed with water to the consistency of cream, and sheets of mica if needed.67

“Which I call a Salamander safe or chest.”

Daniel Fitzgerald, patent specification, 1843

Wilder’s brother Benjamin G. Wilder took over the patent, and Silas C. Herring made the safes, first as agent and later under a licence for New York at one cent a pound.61 When Gayler, the Salamander man himself, and a partner made plaster-filled safes, Wilder sued. In 1850 the US Supreme Court upheld the patent in Gayler v. Wilder, even though Conner’s earlier safe had been used for years; two justices dissented on exactly that point.6 (The 1870 account says Enos Wilder obtained the patent himself; the court record shows it was Fitzgerald’s, assigned to Wilder.)

How the fillings worked

Strip away the paint and brass, and every early fire safe was a box inside a box. What changed was the filling between the walls, which had to slow the heat or soak it up.

Air and clay

Non-conductors

Gayler’s double chest relied on an air gap or a slow conductor. Clay, ashes or sand were still used in cheap safes in 1875.13

Plaster

Plaster of Paris

Heated plaster gives off its combined water as steam. But plaster released moisture in normal use too, making contents damp and rusting the iron through.1

Alum

Sawdust and alum

The standard British filling: sawdust, preferably mahogany, mixed with alum, whose water of crystallisation turns to steam in a fire.3

This is the science behind the “212” on Milner’s badges: as long as water was boiling off inside the walls, the contents should stay at or below 212°F, the boiling point of water.8 The weakness, as George Hayter Chubb pointed out in 1875, is that the alum’s water eventually runs out, after which the sawdust can char. Sawdust also absorbs damp, and some makers had tried glass or metal tubes of liquid buried in the filling, which broke or corroded and soaked the contents.3

American makers had their own version of the problem with plaster. By 1854 rusted-through safes were coming back for repair, and Herring & Co. switched to a powder discovered in 1853 by a Philadelphia chemist, Spear, made from the chalky residue of soda-water making.1

Brass Milner escutcheon badge with the figure 212 and the words fire resisting
A Milner “212” badge. Photo: Shyamal, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Fire trials and the Great Exhibition

Makers sold safes on stories of survival: the Thomaston fire of 1833, the New York fires of 1835 and 1845, and staged public burnings.15 At the Great Exhibition of 1851 Herring’s safe was reported by Scientific American to have come out of forty hours of red heat with its contents unharmed,5 while Milner’s stand, despite the later legend, was nothing more dramatic than a static display of safes at different stages of manufacture.9 More on the British makers at the Exhibition is in the Great Exhibition and the British safe industry.

George Hayter Chubb warned his readers in 1875 to put little faith in public tests unless they were run by disinterested people, because safes could be specially built, contents carefully packed or fires arranged to guarantee a result. Real fires, he thought, were the better evidence: no safe kept inside a strong room had, to his knowledge, ever been destroyed, but many light safes in warehouses and offices had lost their contents.3

Fireproof safes today

“Fireproof” was always a bit of an overstatement, and the trade’s own word was fire-resisting. These days, safes are tested to published standards. In the United States, UL 72 covers the fire resistance of record protection equipment, and its Class 350 rating, intended for paper, requires the inside to stay below 350°F (177°C) for the rated time.1011 European standards grade fire-resisting safes and cabinets in a similar way, by duration and by the material they protect. If you’re buying one for papers, it’s the rating that counts, not the word on the box.

I have an old fire-resisting safe: what now?

Contents

What is inside the walls

Victorian British safes usually hold sawdust and alum; American ones plaster or later powders. Some safes made up to the late 1990s used asbestos in door seals or fire packing.12

Protection

Don’t rely on it

Old fillings dry out, absorb damp or have already done their job once. However handsome it looks, keep important papers in a modern, tested fire safe, not a Victorian one.

Opening

No cutting or drilling

If the filling may contain asbestos, cutting or drilling can release fibres. Ireland’s Health and Safety Authority advises calling a safe technician who can open it without drilling.12 Our guide asks do old safes contain asbestos? and explains what to check.

If the packing is leaking from a pre-2000 safe, the HSA advises taking it out of use and leaving it undisturbed until it has been tested.12 Our guide to buying a second-hand safe covers moving, keys and what an old safe is realistically worth.

Myths about the invention of the fireproof safe

Richard Scott invented the fireproof safe in 1801.

His 1801 patent is the earliest English one we found, but we have found no details of his design or whether it was made.

Thomas Milner invented the fire safe in 1827.

The 1827 date comes from an 1878 American journal. Milner’s first patent is dated 1840.

“Salamander” was one maker’s brand.

It began as a nickname for Gayler’s chest in 1833; Fitzgerald then used it in his patent.

A fireproof safe is fireproof.

Every fire safe only resists fire for a limited time, which is why modern ratings are given in minutes or hours.

Patents in the collection

Frequently asked questions

Who invented the fireproof safe?

No single person. Richard Scott took out an English fireproofing patent in 1801; Jesse Delano (1826), C. J. Gayler (1833) and Daniel Fitzgerald (1843) patented key designs in New York; Milner and Tann patented British fillings in the 1840s.

What is a Salamander safe?

A 19th-century nickname for a fire-resisting safe, after the creature that legend said could live in fire. It was first given to Gayler’s double chest after a fire in 1833 and then used by Fitzgerald, Wilder and Herring for plaster-filled safes.

What were old fireproof safes filled with?

Air gaps, clay or ashes in early and cheap safes; plaster of Paris in many American safes; sawdust mixed with alum in most Victorian British safes.

Do old safes contain asbestos?

Some do. Asbestos was used in door seals and fire packing by some makers into the late 1990s. Treat an old safe’s filling with care and don’t cut or drill it.

When were safes invented?

Locked chests are ancient. Iron chests were common by 1800, and fire-resisting safes developed between about 1801 and the 1840s.

Do fireproof safes really work?

Modern tested safes protect paper for their rated time. A Victorian safe’s filling may be exhausted, so don’t rely on it, however solid it feels.

Sources:
  1. One Hundred Years’ Progress of the United States (Hartford, 1870), section on locks and safes, pp. 396–397, via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  2. The Chubb Archive, Lock Register 1819–1828, lock No. 452. ↩︎
  3. George Hayter Chubb, Protection from Fire and Thieves (1875), chapter IV “Safes against fire” and appendix “List of patents for safes”, via Project Gutenberg. ↩︎
  4. The Chubb Archive, “A brief history of Chubb 1818–1990s”. ↩︎
  5. Early Office Museum, “Antique office safes”, quoting Manufacturer and Builder (May 1878) and Scientific American (16 August 1851; 11 June 1853). ↩︎
  6. US Supreme Court, Gayler v. Wilder, 51 U.S. (10 How.) 477 (1850), including Fitzgerald’s specification, the 1839 assignment to Enos Wilder and James Conner’s evidence, via Cornell LII. ↩︎
  7. Daniel Fitzgerald, US Patent 3,117, “Improvement in fire-proof chests and safes”, 1 June 1843, via Google Patents. ↩︎
  8. safeman.org.uk, “About safes”. ↩︎
  9. Official Descriptive and Illustrated Catalogue of the Great Exhibition (1851), vol. 2, p. 661, exhibit 642 (Milner & Son), via Internet Archive. ↩︎
  10. ANSI Webstore, ANSI/CAN/UL 72:2026, “Tests for Fire Resistance of Record Protection Equipment”. ↩︎
  11. Wikipedia, “Fire-resistance rating” (UL 72 classes). ↩︎
  12. Health and Safety Authority (Ireland), “Asbestos risks in safes and fire resistant cabinets”. ↩︎
Hos Logo
Greg

I work in IT and I'm a designer at heart. I write this blog because safes turned out to be a surprisingly big slice of history and pop culture. Every article here is checked against period catalogues, patents and trade directories, and my favourite story is still the Great Lock Controversy of 1851.

Articles: 136

One comment

  1. My husband and and I just purchased a C.J.Gayler safe. The name IS.? OPPENHEIM is hand painted on the door along with two decorative hand painted designs. We’re looking for info and history of it. Any help or direction wod be very appreciated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.