Hidden Compartment Furniture: Secret Drawers in Antique Desks

Before most homes had a safe, letters, money and papers went into furniture with secret drawers. Museum records show where makers hid them: behind pigeonholes, inside pilasters, under side drawers and in wells and false bases.

1742

Abraham Roentgen opens the workshop famous for trick furniture

80,000

livres paid by Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette for one Roentgen secretary cabinet

1874

year William S. Wooton patented his cabinet desk in Indianapolis

~100

separate compartments in an open Wooton desk

Key takeaways

  • Hidden compartments are most often found in writing furniture: bureaux, bureau cabinets, secretaires and desks, where private letters and valuables were kept.
  • Museum records place them behind pull-out pigeonholes, inside pilasters and plinths, under side drawers, below a prospect door and in wells under sliding panels.
  • Abraham and David Roentgen of Neuwied built the most famous mechanical versions, sold to Louis XVI, Marie Antoinette and Catherine the Great.
  • Searching your own furniture is fine if you’re gentle. A locked secret drawer with no key is a job for a locksmith or a furniture conservator, never for a screwdriver.
  • A secret drawer rarely sets the price on its own: maker, condition and originality do. Auction figures below are examples, not valuations.
Small yellow-veneered rolltop desk by David Roentgen with its top rolled back, showing open pigeonholes and a red leather writing slide pulled out
Rolltop desk by David Roentgen, Neuwied, about 1785 to 1786, probably the one invoiced to Catherine the Great in 1786. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2018.288.1, public domain (Open Access).

Hidden compartment furniture at a glance

What it isFurniture with drawers, wells or boxes hidden inside its structure, usually writing furniture
Main periodAbout 1700 to the late 19th century
Typical piecesBureau, bureau cabinet (desk and bookcase), escritoire, secretaire, rolltop desk, commode, table cabinet
Common hiding placesBehind pigeonholes, inside pilasters or plinths, under side drawers, below a prospect door, in a well under a sliding panel, in a detachable base
Famous makersAbraham and David Roentgen (Neuwied, 1742 to about 1800); Wooton desks (Indianapolis, patent 1874)
What was kept insidePrivate correspondence and valuables, according to the V&A
Where to see themThe Met (New York), V&A (London), Colonial Williamsburg (Virginia)
Locked and no key?A locksmith or a furniture conservator

The short answer to “where would a secret compartment be?” is: in the part of the piece used for writing. That’s where an 18th-century owner kept letters, accounts and money, and it’s where the museum catalogues we went through keep finding them.

Why furniture kept secrets

For most of the 18th century, a household’s private papers didn’t live in a steel box. They lived in a desk. The V&A notes that bureau cabinets, known at the time as desk bookcases, became increasingly common in Britain, Ireland and America from around 1700, and that inventories show them kept mostly in bedrooms and dressing rooms rather than in libraries. Describing an Irish example, the museum says its lockable drawers and secret compartments would most likely have held “private correspondence and valuables”.1

Locks were the first line, and the hiding place was the second. A thief or a nosy servant who forced the fall front would find pigeonholes and small drawers, and might stop there. A Roentgen desk, in Goethe’s description, could reveal “money compartments” along with paper and letters once its springs were set in motion.2 Hiding valuables wasn’t new: Catholic families in Tudor England were hiding whole people, in priest holes built into their houses. A secret drawer is the same idea, scaled down to fit under a writing flap.

Sometimes the hiding place still holds something. Colonial Williamsburg’s escritoire of 1700 to 1720 has secret drawers in a cavity under its side drawers, and its catalogue notes, without fuss, “five scraps of paper found in secret compartment of desk”.3 We’d love to know what they say. The record only tells us they’re kept in the object folder.

The makers who built hidden compartments

Abraham and David Roentgen, Neuwied

If one name is attached to secret drawers, it’s Roentgen. Abraham Roentgen (1711–1793) opened a cabinetmaker’s workshop at Herrnhaag, near Frankfurt am Main, in 1742 and moved it to Neuwied on the Rhine in 1750. His son David (1743–1807) gradually took over between 1765 and 1768, and in 1779 was appointed cabinetmaker-mechanic to Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette. At its peak the workshop employed nearly 200 specialists, and by 1789 Catherine the Great and the Russian nobility had bought hundreds of its pieces.4

The Met’s curator Wolfram Koeppe sums up the appeal: at the turn of a key, many of these pieces “literally unfold to reveal hidden compartments, secret drawers, and mechanical and musical devices”. David brought a grand secretary cabinet to Paris in late 1778, and the royal couple bought it for 80,000 livres, which Koeppe calls the largest amount the royal household ever paid for a single piece of furniture.5

Marquetry rolltop desk on six legs by David Roentgen, open to show its interior drawers and leather writing surface
Rolltop desk by David Roentgen, Neuwied, about 1776 to 1779. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 41.82, public domain (Open Access).

The Met’s rolltop desk of about 1776 to 1779 shows how it worked in practice. Turn the key of the lower drawer and the side drawers spring open; a concealed button then sends each one swinging aside to show three more drawers behind it. Which side opens depends on how the key is turned. David was proud enough of it to inlay his monogram, DR, below the keyhole, and the Met notes his work is rarely signed.6 A V&A commode from the same workshop runs on weight- and spring-driven mechanisms controlled by a single key, with three dummy drawer fronts disguising one long drawer and concealed drawers behind the side doors.2

“A trick writing desk made by Roentgen, with springs and secret drawers that can be set in motion”

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, The New Melusina (1817), as translated by the V&A

The featured image at the top of this page is a later, plainer Roentgen. The Met believes it’s the “small Cylinder-top writing desk of yellow wood” invoiced to Catherine the Great on 23 March 1786 for 250 rubles, plus 90 for transport and packing. Its pigeonholes have stepped platforms that hide spring-operated secret drawers.7 Plain on the outside, busy inside: if you’re a designer, it’s hard not to admire the restraint.

British and Irish cabinetmakers

Most of the secret drawers in the catalogues we read weren’t made by famous names, and few are mechanical. They’re a little drawer behind a pigeonhole or a slim box inside a pilaster, built by a good cabinetmaker as part of the job. Some names do turn up. A walnut bureau cabinet in the V&A was probably made in Dublin by John Kirkhoffer, whose signature, “John Kirkhoffer facit 1732”, is on a closely related cabinet in the Art Institute of Chicago. Two of the marquetry plinths on its upper stage hide secret compartments.1

Thomas Chippendale supplied the actor David Garrick with a painted clothes press, made in London between 1775 and 1778 for Garrick’s villa at Hampton. A narrow door in its decorated side leads to deep drawers and a secret drawer, and the V&A notes it was designed for a particular spot in the room so that the side door could be reached.8 A desk the V&A attributes to Gillow shows another trick, the false front: this mahogany pedestal desk of about 1770 to 1800 has a full-width drawer faced as six small ones, and a back faced with five more dummies.9

Wooton desks, Indianapolis

Engraving of a Wooton cabinet desk standing open, its two hinged wings lined with pigeonholes and letter slots around a fold-down writing flap
A Wooton desk standing open, engraving from McKillop, Walker and Co., Mercantile Register, 1882. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

A century after the Roentgens, the American answer was storage on a heroic scale. William S. Wooton of Indianapolis was granted US Patent 155,604 on 6 October 1874 for a secretary built in three parts, with the two narrower parts hinged to the wider one so they close like doors, and every part fitted with pigeonholes and compartments. The patent mentions one lock, on the outer door.10

Sold as “Wooton’s Patent Cabinet Office Secretary”, it opened to about 100 compartments and a writing desk, won an award at the 1876 Centennial Exhibition in Philadelphia, and counted Jay Gould, Ulysses S. Grant, Joseph Pulitzer and John D. Rockefeller among its owners. Queen Victoria reportedly had one too. Wooton himself left the firm in 1880.11

A Wooton isn’t really a secret-drawer desk: it’s a filing system you can lock. But one sold at auction from the Milhous Collection shows where the idea was heading. Its doors have letter slots, one marked “LETTERS”, and inside there’s an integrated safe by Martin of New York. The catalogue gives Wooton production as 1874 to 1891.12

Timeline

  • c. 1700 Bureau cabinets (desk bookcases) become increasingly common in Britain, Ireland and America.
  • 1732 John Kirkhoffer signs a Dublin bureau cabinet of the type with hidden plinth compartments.
  • 1742 Abraham Roentgen opens his workshop at Herrnhaag; it moves to Neuwied in 1750.
  • 1775–1778 Chippendale’s workshop makes Garrick’s clothes press with a secret drawer.
  • 1778 David Roentgen brings a secretary cabinet to Paris; Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette buy it for 80,000 livres.
  • 1786 A small Roentgen rolltop desk with spring-operated secret drawers is invoiced to Catherine the Great.
  • 1817 Goethe compares a fairy palace to a Roentgen trick desk in The New Melusina.
  • 1874 William S. Wooton patents his cabinet secretary in Indianapolis.
  • 1910 Meilink patents a wall safe for offices, hotels, apartments and residences.

Where secret compartments hide

We read through the catalogue records of the V&A, the Met and Colonial Williamsburg looking for the phrases “secret drawer” and “secret compartment”. The same few places come up again and again, and nearly all are in the writing section of the piece. An English bureau cabinet of 1710 to 1730 is typical: behind its fall front, supported on pull-out lopers, sit a range of small drawers and two secret compartments.13

Bureau

Behind the pigeonholes

In an English bureau-cabinet of 1700 to 1725, each pair of pigeonholes pulls out to show a secret drawer behind, and a well sits under sliding panels.14

Desk and bookcase

Around the prospect door

On a Virginia desk of about 1795, a thin board under the central prospect drawer slides out to reveal a secret compartment.15

Cabinet

In the pilasters and base

An English bureau bookcase of 1720 to 1740 hides compartments in pull-out pilasters beside its mirrored cupboard.16

Hiding placeMuseum exampleWhat the record says
Pull-out pigeonholesBureau-cabinet, England, 1700–1725 (V&A)Each pair of pigeonholes pulls out to reveal a secret drawer
Well under sliding panelsSame bureau-cabinet (V&A)Interior well covered by sliding panels
PilastersBureau bookcase, England, 1720–1740 (V&A)Secret compartments in the pull-out pilasters
PlinthsBureau cabinet, Dublin, 1730–1740 (V&A)The outer two plinths conceal secret compartments
Fall-front interiorBureau cabinet, England, 1710–1730 (V&A)Small drawers and two secret compartments behind the fall front
Under the side drawersEscritoire, America, 1700–1720 (Colonial Williamsburg)Secret drawers in the cavity under the side drawers
Below the prospect drawerDesk and bookcase, Virginia, c. 1795 (Colonial Williamsburg)A thin board slides out to reveal a secret compartment
Detachable baseTable cabinet, England, c. 1740 (V&A)Secret wells reachable only with the drawer removed and the base detached
Side doorClothes press, Chippendale, 1775–1778 (V&A)A narrow side door leads to drawers and a secret drawer
Dummy drawer frontsDavenport, England, 1840–1860 (V&A)One side has four drawers, the other false drawers to match
Sources: V&A, Colonial Williamsburg and Met catalogue records cited in this article.

Two details in that list are worth a second look. The Dublin cabinet’s “drawer fronts” are partly fake: two dummy fronts and the two inner plinths make up the face of one wide, deep drawer, while the outer plinths are the hiding places.1 And the oak table cabinet of about 1740 has no locks at all. Its top right drawer opens only with a secret catch, and another compartment in the base can be reached only by taking out the drawer and lifting the cabinet off its detachable base.17 It was given to the V&A in 1937 by a collector who listed it, more modestly, as a “spice cabinet”.

Victorian Davenports, the small sloping-topped writing desks, show the same thinking in a cheaper form. The V&A’s burr walnut example of 1840 to 1860 has four working drawers on one side and a panelled side made to match them with false drawers.18 False drawers aren’t secret compartments in themselves, but they tell you the maker was happy to let the outside lie about the inside.

Did you know?

The V&A’s Dublin bureau cabinet was once believed to be Jonathan Swift’s, because of an inscription found under a top drawer read as “Mrs McAndrews … Mr Swifts House”. The museum calls the Swift history uncertain, but it’s a good reminder to look under drawers as well as behind them.1

How to look for a secret compartment without damaging the piece

Searching your own furniture is harmless as long as you treat it like the museum objects above: slowly, with nothing sharper than your fingers. Here’s the order we’d follow, built from where those records actually found things.

  1. Photograph everything first. Take pictures of the closed piece, then of each section as you open it, so every drawer goes back where it came from.
  2. Take out the interior drawers one by one. Look under each drawer and behind it. The Dublin cabinet’s inscription was under a top drawer, and the Williamsburg escritoire’s secret drawers sit in the cavity under its side drawers.
  3. Compare inside and outside. Measure the depth of a pigeonhole or drawer against the depth of the case. A gap of a few centimetres at the back or below is where a secret drawer or well would sit.
  4. Check the classic spots. Pigeonhole units that might pull out as a whole, the pilasters either side of a central cupboard, the board under a prospect door, the floor of the writing well, and any dummy drawer front.
  5. Never force anything. If a part doesn’t move with light pressure, stop. Old glue, swollen wood and fragile veneer give way long before a hidden catch does.
  6. Write down what you find. Note any paper, labels or inscriptions where they lie, before you touch them, and keep them with the piece.

Moving the piece to get at the back or the base needs care too. Icon, the UK’s Institute of Conservation, advises lifting furniture straight up at its strongest point, with at least two people for most pieces, never tipping or dragging it, leaving nothing on it that could come loose, and locking doors and drawers that stay in. It also warns that “the effects of inappropriate treatment can be worse (and more costly) than if the piece had been left alone”.19

If the hidden drawer is locked

Some secret drawers and desk strongboxes have their own lock, and the key is often long gone. That’s the point to stop searching and call someone: a locksmith who works on antique furniture locks, or a furniture conservator, who can open it without splitting the drawer front or tearing the veneer. Don’t try to lever or drill it yourself. On a piece like this the lock and the wood around it are part of what the furniture is worth.

The same goes for a real safe built into a desk, like the Martin safe inside the Wooton above. If yours has a maker’s name or number on it, send us photos of the safe’s plate and any numbers and we’ll help you work out who made it. Opening it is still a job for a qualified safe engineer.

What is furniture with secret drawers worth?

There’s no price for “has a secret drawer”. What sells a piece is the maker, the condition, how original it is and, for the grandest pieces, who owned it. The Roentgen figures above, 80,000 livres for a royal secretary cabinet and 250 rubles for Catherine’s small desk, show how wide the range was even inside one workshop.57

Wooton desks give the clearest modern picture, because they turn up at auction fairly often. Here are three results we could check directly.

DeskSaleFigure
Wooton patent walnut rotary desk, second half of the 19th centuryFreeman’s, sale 530Estimate US$2,000–$4,000
“Extra grade” Wooton desk, patent 1874, with replacements and repainted gildingPook & Pook, September 2007Sold for $18,000 before buyer’s premium (estimate $15,000–$25,000)
Wooton patent desk, about 1875–1880, with letter slots and a built-in Martin safeRM Sotheby’s, Milhous CollectionSold for $25,300
Sources: Freeman’s lot 694, Pook & Pook lot 149, RM Sotheby’s lot 224.

So the same patent spans roughly an order of magnitude, from a few thousand dollars for a plain rotary desk to about $25,000 for the big cabinet “secretaries” in good original condition.202112 The difference is model and grade, condition and originality, not hidden compartments.

These figures are past auction estimates and results, quoted as examples. They’re an informal guide, not a professional appraisal, and they won’t tell you what your own piece is worth. For that, ask an auction house or an accredited furniture valuer to see it.

Every antique desk has a secret drawer somewhere.

Museum catalogues mention them only on some pieces. Plenty of fine desks have none, and a plain one isn’t missing anything.

Secret compartments were all clever spring mechanisms.

Springs were a Roentgen speciality. Most hiding places in the records are simple: a drawer behind a pigeonhole, a sliding board, a box in a pilaster.

A secret drawer makes a piece much more valuable.

Maker, condition and originality set the price. Wooton desks with the same patent sell from a few thousand to tens of thousands of dollars.

The Wooton desk was a secret-drawer desk.

Its patent is about three hinged parts full of pigeonholes, with a lock on the outer door. Its selling point was organisation, not concealment.

From secret drawer to home safe

Hiding things in furniture never really stopped, but by the late 19th century valuables were moving into iron and steel. The Martin safe built into that Wooton desk is the two ideas in one piece of furniture.12 Before that, small portable boxes had done the job, from Armada chests to japanned cash boxes; our guide to antique strongboxes and cash boxes covers the ones you’re most likely to find in a desk drawer today.

By the early 1900s a home safe was a mail-order item. In September 1902 Meilink of Toledo advertised its Home Deposit Vault in The Saturday Evening Post under the headline “$8.00 To Protect Your Valuables”.22 In 1910 the same firm patented a wall safe for offices, hotels, apartments and residences, with a rim that hides its fixings.23 The concealment had moved from the desk into the wall, and the full story of how safes reached ordinary homes is in our history of safes.

The furniture idea lives on in other forms. A hollow book on a shelf works on the same principle as a drawer behind a pigeonhole, as our piece on book safes and hidden-book boxes shows, and Japanese and European craftsmen built whole boxes around a hidden way in, covered in our guide to puzzle boxes.

Frequently asked questions

How do I find a hidden compartment in an antique desk?

Photograph the piece, then take out the small interior drawers and look behind and under them. Compare inside depths with the outside of the case, and check pull-out pigeonholes, pilasters, the board under a prospect door and the floor of the writing well. Never force a part that won’t move.

Where are secret drawers usually located?

In the writing section. Museum records place them behind pigeonholes, inside pilasters and plinths, in cavities under side drawers, beneath a prospect door and in wells under sliding panels.

The secret drawer is locked and there’s no key. What now?

Call a locksmith who works on antique furniture, or a furniture conservator. They can open it without damaging the drawer or veneer. Don’t lever or drill it.

Who made furniture with secret compartments?

Many ordinary cabinetmakers did. The best known are Abraham and David Roentgen of Neuwied, whose mechanical desks went to European royalty. Thomas Chippendale and Dublin’s John Kirkhoffer also made pieces with secret drawers now in the V&A.

What is a Wooton desk worth?

It depends on the model, grade and condition. The results we checked run from an estimate of US$2,000–$4,000 for a rotary desk to $18,000 and $25,300 for large cabinet desks. That’s an informal guide, not an appraisal.

Is a hidden compartment the same as a safe?

No. A secret drawer works by not being found; a safe is built to resist someone who knows exactly where it is. Some later desks combined both, like the Wooton with a Martin safe inside.

Sources:
  1. Victoria and Albert Museum, Bureau cabinet, probably by John Kirkhoffer, Dublin, 1730 to 1740, museum number W.32:1-1912, catalogue record. ↩︎
  2. Victoria and Albert Museum, Commode, workshop of David Roentgen, Neuwied, 1776 to 1779, museum number W.51:1 to 16-1948, catalogue record. Includes the museum’s translation of Goethe’s The New Melusina (published 1817). ↩︎
  3. Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, Escritoire, America, 1700 to 1720, object number 1960-667, catalogue record. ↩︎
  4. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, press release for Extravagant Inventions: The Princely Furniture of the Roentgens (exhibition 30 October 2012 to 27 January 2013), dated 10 December 2012. ↩︎
  5. Wolfram Koeppe, “Abraham and David Roentgen”, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1 June 2013. ↩︎
  6. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Rolltop desk, David Roentgen, about 1776 to 1779, object number 41.82, catalogue entry. ↩︎
  7. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Rolltop desk, David Roentgen, about 1785 to 1786, object number 2018.288.1, catalogue entry. ↩︎
  8. Victoria and Albert Museum, Clothes press, Thomas Chippendale, London, 1775 to 1778, museum number W.22:1 to 8-1917, catalogue record. ↩︎
  9. Victoria and Albert Museum, Desk, Gillow, England, about 1770 to 1800, museum number W.28:1-1950, catalogue record. ↩︎
  10. William S. Wooton, US Patent 155,604, “Improvement in Secretaries”, granted 6 October 1874 (application filed 11 March 1874). ↩︎
  11. Ray Boomhower, “Wooton Patent Desks”, Encyclopedia of Indianapolis (1994, revised March 2021). ↩︎
  12. RM Sotheby’s, The Milhous Collection, lot 224, Wooton patent desk, result listed as sold for US$25,300. ↩︎
  13. Victoria and Albert Museum, Bureau cabinet, England, 1710 to 1730, museum number W.7:1 to 25-1959, catalogue record. ↩︎
  14. Victoria and Albert Museum, Bureau-cabinet, England, 1700 to 1725, museum number W.9:54-1960, catalogue record. ↩︎
  15. Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, Desk and bookcase, Frederick County, Virginia, about 1795, object number 1930-68, catalogue record. ↩︎
  16. Victoria and Albert Museum, Bureau bookcase, England, 1720 to 1740, museum number W.51:1-1938, catalogue record. ↩︎
  17. Victoria and Albert Museum, Table cabinet, England, about 1740, museum number W.54-1937, catalogue record. ↩︎
  18. Victoria and Albert Museum, Davenport, England, 1840 to 1860, museum number W.49:15-1931, catalogue record. ↩︎
  19. Icon, the Institute of Conservation, “Furniture”, collections care guide. ↩︎
  20. Freeman’s, Fine Furniture and Decorative Arts, sale 530, lot 694, Wooton patent walnut rotary desk, estimate US$2,000 to $4,000. ↩︎
  21. Pook & Pook, lot 149, American “extra grade” Wooton desk, September 2007: estimate US$15,000 to $25,000, sold for $18,000 before buyer’s premium. ↩︎
  22. Meilink, “$8.00 To Protect Your Valuables: Meilink’s Home Deposit Vault”, advert in The Saturday Evening Post, 13 September 1902 (scan in the History of Safes adverts collection). ↩︎
  23. Charles F. Meilink and William H. Reynolds, US Patent 960,982, “Wall-safe”, granted 7 June 1910. ↩︎

The History of Safes letter

One old safe a month, in your inbox

Once a month I send one safe worth a closer look, the new maker histories and a find from the patent and advert collection. Nothing else, and you can leave with one click.

You'll get a confirmation email first. One email a month, unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy.

Hos Logo
Greg

I work in IT and I'm a designer at heart. I write this blog because safes turned out to be a surprisingly big slice of history and pop culture. Every article here is checked against period catalogues, patents and trade directories, and my favourite story is still the Great Lock Controversy of 1851.

Articles: 178

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.